How to Sell More Gift Cards This Holiday Season (9 Tactics for Local Businesses)
Short answer: gift cards are the only thing you can sell at 9pm on December 24, they bring a new customer into your business who did not choose you themselves, and the person redeeming one typically spends beyond the card value. For most local businesses they are the highest-leverage holiday product available, and most are doing almost nothing to sell them.
Here is how to fix that in the weeks you have left.
Why gift cards matter more than owners think
Three things happen when you sell one:
You get paid before you deliver. Cash comes in during your highest-expense month.
You acquire a customer you did not have to find. The recipient did not choose you. Someone who trusts you chose you on their behalf, which is a referral with money attached.
Redemption usually exceeds the card value. People treat a gift card as a discount rather than a budget, and they spend past it. Some cards are never redeemed at all.
That third point comes with a responsibility: honor your cards. Local businesses that quibble over expired cards destroy goodwill for a small amount of money.
The 9 tactics
1. Make buying one take under 60 seconds
This is the whole game. Every extra step cuts sales sharply, and gift card buyers are, by definition, in a hurry.
Test it yourself right now, on your phone, as if you were a stranger. Time it. If buying a gift card from your business takes more than a minute, or requires calling during business hours, or requires visiting in person, that is your first fix and it is worth more than everything else on this list.
You want a digital gift card that can be bought and delivered by email in one sitting. Most point-of-sale systems and booking platforms already include this and owners never turn it on.
2. Put the link everywhere a person might look
Not buried in a menu. Specifically:
- A visible button in your website header, not the footer
- Your Google Business Profile, as a product and a link
- Your Instagram and Facebook bio links
- Your email signature
- A pinned social post
- A QR code at your register, on your receipts, and on your table tents
- Your voicemail greeting from mid-November through Christmas Eve
3. Sell the occasion, not the card
"Gift cards available" is a sign. It is not marketing.
Name who the card solves a problem for:
- "For the neighbor who watched your dog"
- "For the coworker you drew in the gift exchange"
- "For your mother-in-law who says she doesn't want anything"
- "For the teacher, the mail carrier, the person who plows your driveway"
People do not wake up wanting a gift card. They wake up stuck on a specific person. Name that person and you have made the sale.
4. Bundle it into something physical
A plastic or paper card in an envelope is a weak gift and people know it. A card tucked into something small changes the perception entirely: a bag of your coffee, a small product, a nice card in a proper sleeve, a candle, a sample.
The bundle costs you a few dollars, raises the average purchase, and makes the buyer feel like they gave a real gift instead of an IOU. Charge for the bundle or absorb it as a promotion. Either works.
5. Run a bonus card promotion instead of a discount
The classic local business promotion, and it works because the math favors you.
"Buy a $50 gift card, get a $10 card for yourself." The buyer feels rewarded, you collect $50 today, and the $10 card brings that same person back in January, which is a slow month for almost everybody.
Cap it, date it, and make the bonus card expire in a window that helps your slow season. This outperforms straight discounting because you are not devaluing what you sell.
6. Sell three tiers, and put your recommended one in the middle
Do not just offer an open amount field. Most people have no idea what to spend and will pick a smaller number out of uncertainty.
Give them $25, $50, and $100, with $50 marked as the popular choice. Average card value goes up simply because you told them what normal looks like.
7. Train your team on one sentence
The single biggest source of gift card sales in a physical business is a person asking.
Give your staff one line and have them use it from mid-November through Christmas Eve: "Are you shopping for anyone else today? Our gift cards are right here and I can do one in about thirty seconds."
Post it by the register. Practice it out loud once.
8. Push hardest in the last 96 hours
Here is the thing to internalize about this year's calendar. Christmas falls on a Friday, December 25, 2026, which means the last-minute window runs Monday December 21 through Thursday December 24 and it will be busy.
By December 21, every shipping deadline and every custom order deadline has passed. Gift cards are the only thing left that anyone can buy. That is your window and almost nobody markets into it.
Send an email on December 22 and again on the morning of December 24 with one message: still time, buy in a minute, delivered instantly. Post the same thing. Your open rates will be high because everyone else has gone quiet and the people reading are actively panicking.
9. Market the redemption, not just the sale
Most owners forget the second half. Every card you sold is a customer who has not walked in yet.
In early January, post and email about redemption. "Got a gift card? We're open, here's what's new." January is slow for most local businesses, and you are sitting on a list of people with money already spent at your business who just need a nudge.
The mistakes that cost real money
Making it hard to buy. Worth repeating because it is the top cause of lost gift card revenue.
Hiding it after Christmas. Gift cards sell year-round for birthdays, weddings, graduations, teacher gifts, and thank-yous. Keep the link up.
Fighting over expiration. Federal rules restrict how quickly gift card funds can expire, and state laws vary and are often stricter, so check your state's requirements. Beyond the legal question, refusing an old card over a small balance buys you a bad review and costs you a customer. Honor it.
No tracking. Know how many you sold, what the average value was, and what percentage got redeemed. Those three numbers tell you whether to expand the program next year.
Not saying it out loud. A sign is not an ask. People need to be asked.
If you do not sell gift cards yet
You can start this month. Check whether your existing point-of-sale, booking, or e-commerce system already supports them, because it very likely does. Turn it on, set your three tiers, add the link to your website header and your Google Business Profile, print a QR code for the counter, and train the one sentence.
That is an afternoon of work for a revenue line that will keep producing every December and every birthday season after.
Where this fits in the season
Gift cards are one piece of a larger Q4 plan. The full month-by-month version is in the holiday marketing countdown, the profile setup is in getting your Google Business Profile ready for the holidays, and the emails and posts that sell them are written out in the holiday email and social calendar.
One last framing worth holding onto. A gift card is somebody vouching for you with their own money and their own reputation. That is the same trust that drives referrals and reviews, and it is the thing a large chain cannot manufacture locally. Treat the recipient like the referral they are.
Start my local advertising plan
Frequently asked questions
Should a small business sell gift cards? For most local businesses, yes. Gift cards generate cash before delivery, bring in customers who did not choose you themselves, and are frequently redeemed for more than the card value. They are also the only product you can sell in the final days before Christmas after every other deadline has passed.
How do I sell more gift cards? Make buying one take under a minute online, put the link in your website header and Google Business Profile, name the specific people the card solves a gift problem for, bundle it with something physical, offer a bonus card instead of a discount, present three price tiers with a recommended middle option, and have your team ask out loud at checkout.
Is a bonus gift card promotion better than a discount? Usually yes. A bonus card such as "buy $50, get $10" collects the full amount today, avoids devaluing your prices, and brings the buyer back during a slower month when the bonus card is redeemed.
When do gift cards sell the most? The final four days before Christmas, when all shipping and custom order deadlines have passed. In 2026 that window is December 21 through 24, since Christmas falls on a Friday. Cyber Monday is also strong, because gift cards are the one thing local businesses can deliver instantly online.
Do gift cards expire? Federal rules limit how quickly gift card funds can expire and many states have stricter requirements, so check the law where you operate. Regardless of the legal minimum, honoring old cards is almost always the better business decision, since disputing a small balance costs you a customer and often a public review.
What should I do with gift cards after the holidays? Market redemption in January. Every unredeemed card is a customer who has already paid and has not visited yet, and January is a slow month for most local businesses. Keep the gift card link up year-round for birthdays, weddings, and thank-you gifts.